Car Brand Safety Rankings

26 manufacturers ranked by sales-weighted driver death rates β€” which brands actually keep their drivers alive?

How We Rank Brands

We take every model from each brand in the IIHS death rate dataset and compute a sales-weighted average. This means a brand's best-selling models matter more than niche ones β€” the Camry matters more than the Supra for Toyota's score.

πŸ“Š

Sales-Weighted

Popular models count more than low-volume ones β€” reflects what people actually drive.

πŸ’€

Real Death Rates

Not crash test scores β€” actual driver fatalities per million registered vehicle years.

πŸš—

181 Models

Across 26 brands from the IIHS 2018–2021 dataset.

πŸ† Full Brand Rankings

Rank Brand Weighted Avg Death Rate Models in Dataset Best Model Worst Model Grade
1 BMW 2.8 2 BMW X3 4WD (0) BMW X5 4WD (6) A+
2 Volvo 4.5 2 Volvo XC90 4WD (4) Volvo XC60 4WD (5) A+
3 Audi 5.8 3 Audi Q5 4WD (2) Audi A4 4WD (17) A+
4 Lexus 5.9 6 Lexus ES 350 (0) Lexus NX 300 4WD (13) A+
5 Porsche 6.0 1 Porsche Macan (6) Porsche Macan (6) A+
6 Acura 9.8 4 Acura RDX 4WD (6) Acura TLX 2WD (31) A+
7 GMC 18.0 7 GMC Canyon Crew Cab 4WD (5) GMC Yukon 2WD (24) A
8 Subaru 18.2 7 Subaru Outback (5) Subaru Impreza sedan (46) A
9 Mercedes-Benz 22.6 6 Mercedes-Benz E-Class sedan 4WD (0) Mercedes-Benz CLA-Class 2WD (64) B
10 Cadillac 26.4 2 Cadillac Escalade 4WD (26) Cadillac Escalade ESV 4WD (27) B
11 Honda 28.9 11 Honda Odyssey (6) Honda Civic hatchback (78) B
12 Genesis 30.0 1 Genesis G80 (30) Genesis G80 (30) B
13 Jeep 32.2 11 Jeep Grand Cherokee 4WD (12) Jeep Cherokee 2WD (55) B
14 Ram 35.1 9 Ram 1500 Classic Quad Cab 4WD (23) Ram 2500 Mega Cab 4WD (65) C
15 Ford 36.4 18 Ford Edge 4WD (6) Ford Mustang convertible (97) C
16 Chrysler 38.0 3 Chrysler Pacifica 2WD (20) Chrysler 300 4WD (100) C
17 Volkswagen 40.2 2 Volkswagen Atlas 4WD (20) Volkswagen Jetta (47) C
18 Toyota 40.5 15 Toyota C-HR (2) Toyota Corolla (58) C
19 Chevrolet 42.5 24 Chevrolet Traverse 4WD (6) Chevrolet Spark (151) C
20 Buick 43.1 6 Buick Enclave 4WD (23) Buick Encore 2WD (64) C
21 Tesla 46.0 3 Tesla Model 3 2WD (15) Tesla Model 3 4WD (52) C
22 Nissan 58.9 10 Nissan Pathfinder 2WD (0) Nissan Altima (113) D
23 Mitsubishi 63.2 6 Mitsubishi Outlander Sport 4WD (28) Mitsubishi Mirage G4 (205) D
24 Dodge 69.6 8 Dodge Durango 4WD (24) Dodge Challenger 2WD (154) D
25 Hyundai 71.7 6 Hyundai Santa Fe 2WD (17) Hyundai Accent (152) F
26 Kia 76.8 8 Kia Sorento 4WD (26) Kia Rio sedan (122) F

Grades: A+ (<10), A (10–20), B (20–35), C (35–50), D (50–70), F (>70). Death rates are driver fatalities only per million registered vehicle years (not passengers). Why driver-only? β†’

πŸ’‘ Key Takeaways

πŸ… Luxury brands lead β€” but not all of them

BMW, Volvo, Lexus, and Audi consistently produce vehicles with the lowest death rates. This is a combination of better safety engineering, heavier vehicles, and more cautious driving demographics.

βš–οΈ Volume brands vary wildly

Toyota and Honda span from excellent (Sienna, Odyssey) to mediocre. Chevrolet and Ford have huge range β€” from safe trucks to dangerous subcompacts. Brand alone isn't enough; model choice matters enormously.

⚠️ Budget brands suffer

Mitsubishi, Dodge, and Kia cluster at the bottom. Their lineups include many small, lightweight cars and high-powered muscle cars that drive up average death rates.

πŸ”‘ Size is the great equalizer

Across all brands, larger vehicles (SUVs, trucks) dramatically outperform smaller ones. A budget SUV from Chevrolet is safer than a luxury sports car from BMW. Choose size over badge.

Explore by Vehicle

See individual vehicle rankings and reliability data.

Safest Used Cars β†’ Most Dangerous Cars β†’